I never have any trouble explaining the discrepancy. I have donors who are also patients, so it happens enough for me to be quite good at it. I simply say, "Mr. Smith, as a donor you are Rh positive because you make at least a portion of the D antigen, which is called the Rh antigen. Your blood could cause a recipient to make the anti-D antibody. But, as a patient you are Rh negative because you could make anti-D should you receive Rh positive blood. You could possibly make this red-cell destructive antibody even though you make a portion of the D antigen." I have never had this explanation questioned. I only run into this problem with one in 10,000 donations. However, if I were to tell all donors their weak D status, I would be on the phone continuously explaining this. So, no, we don't explain weak D up front when giving donors or patients their blood types. BC