Jalomache - to answer your questions, the samples were run the same day fresh, not frozen, from the primary tube, using manual Gel and then immediately placed on the ECHO. We drained the sample and asked for a redraw and saw the exact same results (4+ D in Gel; Negative Screen, Negative ID on the ECHO). No clerical errors and according to the transfer hospital and the patient, she had not received Rhogam. I agree with you, though, you can't always believe the patient! Immucor was telling me it may have been a newly developing IgM Anti-D so gel would find it, but not the ECHO because according to their literature, ECHO's only pick up IgG antibodies. I'm not sure I believe that response.