We have evaluated, correlated and validated the Immucor and Ortho Fetal screen kits. The Immucor Kit is overly strong for the positive control, usually finding all the rosettes you need in one field. Whereas the Ortho kit pos control has been equivalently representative of a small bleed in a patient, and therefore more realistic for comparison. We have had several false positive results with the Immucor kit, going so far as to being part of the 17% of participants that had falsely reported a Proficiency sample as being positive, when the intended result was negative for one of the two analytes on a Proficiency from API (due to the poorly performing Immucor kit). Immucor blamed the saline used for the "false positives," stating we needed to use PHIX buffer to correct "our" problem. However, the package insert makes no mention of the PHIX buffer, and that is a shady suggestion at best in my opinion to cover their bad product. I am switching to the Ortho Kit that has validated absolutely perfectly. If you are having trouble with the Ortho kit, perhaps your centrifuge calibration is not what it needs to be because we have been using it with a 15second spin and it is working just fine for us. The G-force matters rather than the RPM. The real positives were positive, and the real negatives were negative with the Ortho kit. Staff even commented how much better they like the Ortho kit, citing it was more realistic to the patient testing.